the knowledge which he purveys in his arts as a commodity rather than as a wisdom.” The printed book will naturally tend to become a work of reference rather than a speaking wisdom. Scribal culture and Gothic architecture were both concerned with light through, not light on. * The scholastic deviation from the monastic literary humanism was soon to be confronted by the flood of ancient texts from the printing presses. Four centuries of dialectical intensity seemed to end there; but the spirit and achievement of scholastic science and abstraction was carried along, as men like Clagett have shown, into the full tide of modern science. The scholastic discovery of visual means of graphing non-